# Stay AI pricing, reviews and alternatives: what it costs at your size

Stay AI: $299 a month + 1% + 19¢ a transaction (Nov 17, 2026). Its site says annual contract; its App Store listing says monthly. Cost by size, reviews, alternatives.

OpenSubs publishes this page. We make one of the apps compared here.

Stay AI, the Shopify subscription app, costs $299 a month plus 1% + 19¢ per transaction on its Standard plan. Stay's pricing page ties the $299 to an annual contract and lists $499 a month with no contract. Its Shopify App Store listing sells the same $299 as a "Monthly Plan" with a 30-day free trial. The two pages differ, so get your term in writing. High Growth is custom priced (as of Nov 17, 2026: [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing), [App Store listing](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions)).

At $1M a year in subscription revenue and a $40 average order, Standard costs $18,338 a year (1.83%). That is less than Recharge and Skio, and more than Loop, Appstle, Seal, Shopify Subscriptions and OpenSubs. Our [guide to Shopify subscription apps](/blog/best-shopify-subscription-apps) compares every app.

---

Every price here comes from each vendor's own pricing page, help center or Shopify App Store listing, read on the date shown. No vendor paid for a place on this page, and there are no affiliate links.

---

## What does Stay AI cost?

Stay AI sells two plans: Standard at $299 a month plus 1% + 19¢ per transaction, and High Growth at a custom price. Standard costs $499 a month if you want no contract ([stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing), as of Nov 17, 2026).

*Stay AI's prices and terms, as of Nov 17, 2026. List prices in USD, before payment processing.*

| What | Stay AI's terms | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Standard, annual contract | $299 a month ($3,588 a year) + 1% + 19¢ per transaction. "All features included." | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |
| Standard, no contract | $499 a month. No rate is stated beside it. Stay's compare pages answer "How much does Stay AI cost?" with "$499 per month and 1% + $0.19 per transaction", but the same page's table lists Stay at "$299/Month". Ask Stay for the no-contract rate. | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing), [compare page](https://stay.ai/stay-vs-recharge/) |
| App Store "Monthly Plan" | $299 a month + 1% + 19¢, "billed every 30 days", 30-day free trial | [App Store listing](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions) |
| High Growth | "Custom pricing". Where it starts is not published. | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |
| Free plan | None listed | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |
| Setup and migration | "There is no implementation charge when signing up/ migrating to Stay." | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |
| Account manager | "All Stay plans come with a dedicated account manager and support team." | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |

## Does the $299 plan need an annual contract?

It depends on which Stay page you read. The pricing page says yes. The App Store listing sells the same $299 as a monthly plan and names no contract.

*Three Stay pages on the $299 term, read Nov 17, 2026.*

| [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) | [App Store listing](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions) | [Stay's blog](https://stay.ai/blog/recharge-vs-skio-vs-stay-ai/), Nov 13, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| "$299 /month + 1% + 19¢ per transaction (annual contract)" and "$499/month no contract." | "Monthly Plan $299 / month 1% + 19¢ per transaction 30-day free trial" | "Stay AI pricing starts at $299/month with annual billing" |

None of them says if the contract renews by itself or what leaving early costs. Ask Stay which term applies, and get the term, renewal and exit terms in writing.

**What the choice costs.** No contract costs ($499 − $299) × 12 = $2,400 a year more, if the same 1% + 19¢ applies. A 12-month contract commits you to $3,588. If the contract binds you for all 12 months, month to month costs less only when you leave within 7 months ($499 × 7 = $3,493).

**The contract is new.** In 2023 Stay's pricing page said "No long-term contracts!" ([Wayback, Feb 7, 2023](https://web.archive.org/web/20230207135721/https://stay.ai/pricing/)).

## Why do other pages say $499?

Because $499 a month plus 1% + 19¢ was Stay's list price until at least Oct 10, 2026. We found no Stay announcement of the cut, so we do not know the exact day.

*Stay AI's list price over time, from archived copies of Stay's pages and an outside report.*

| Date | What it showed | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Jun 15, 2025 | "Pro Plan", $499 a month + 1% + 19¢, "30-Day Free Trial" | [stay.ai/pricing (Wayback)](https://web.archive.org/web/20250615203334/https://stay.ai/pricing/) |
| Oct 10, 2026 | "Pro Plan", $499 a month + 1% + 19¢, the last copy before the cut | [stay.ai/pricing (Wayback)](https://web.archive.org/web/20261010061057/https://stay.ai/pricing) |
| Nov 13, 2026 | $299 annual or $499 with no contract, seen by RetainUP, an agency that sets up Stay AI | [RetainUP](https://retainup.co/stay-ai-retention-setup/) |
| Nov 17, 2026 | $299 annual or $499 with no contract; App Store $299 "Monthly Plan" | [stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing) |

So "Pro Plan, $499" was Stay's plan name and price until at least Oct 10, 2026. Today the plan is Standard.

## What does the 1% + 19¢ apply to?

Stay doesn't say today. Its pricing page doesn't define a transaction, and none of the 135 articles in its help center covers merchant billing (read Nov 17, 2026).

In 2023 and 2024 its pricing page said: "A transaction is any order that includes a subscription product" ([Wayback, Jul 16, 2024](https://web.archive.org/web/20240716001412/https://stay.ai/pricing/)). By Jun 2025, the page no longer gave that answer.

Recharge and Skio publish their base (read Nov 17, 2026). Recharge charges on "both one-time and recurring subscription orders", "including shipping, taxes, and refunded orders" ([Recharge Help Center](https://support.getrecharge.com/hc/en-us/articles/360008682914-Recharge-billing-and-pricing)). Skio: "If any subscription product is present, the fee applies to the entire order total" ([Skio Help Center](https://help.skio.com/help/docs/reading-and-understanding-skio-billing)). Loop doesn't publish its base either.

Ask Stay if one-time orders, shipping, tax and refunds count. For why apps charge a share of revenue, see [how Shopify recurring payments work](/blog/shopify-recurring-payments).

## What will Stay AI cost at my size?

At list price and a $40 average order, Stay AI Standard on the annual contract costs $5,063 a year at $100k in subscription revenue. It costs $18,338 at $1M and $77,338 at $5M.

*Stay AI Standard, yearly cost by subscription revenue. List price as of Nov 17, 2026, $40 average order, before payment processing.*

| Yearly revenue | $299, annual contract | Share | $499, no contract (if the 1% + 19¢ applies) | Share |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| $50k | $4,325.50 | 8.65% | $6,725.50 | 13.45% |
| $100k | $5,063 | 5.06% | $7,463 | 7.46% |
| $250k | $7,275.50 | 2.91% | $9,675.50 | 3.87% |
| $500k | $10,963 | 2.19% | $13,363 | 2.67% |
| $1M | $18,338 | 1.83% | $20,738 | 2.07% |
| $5M | $77,338 | 1.55% | $79,738 | 1.59% |
| $10M | $151,088 | 1.51% | $153,488 | 1.53% |
| $20M | $298,588 | 1.49% | $300,988 | 1.50% |

The share falls toward 1.475% as you grow (formula under "Sources, method and change log"). High Growth is custom, so a large brand may pay less.

For the longer story of why subscription apps charge this way, read [how Shopify subscriptions work](https://www.opensubs.com/how-shopify-subscriptions-work).

## What does Stay AI say it does?

Stay sells itself on retention and a move its team does for you. In its own words (read Nov 17, 2026):

- **Cancel flows.** "RetentionEngine includes the original no-code cancel flow builder" ([churn page](https://stay.ai/product/churn-prevention/)).
- **Experiments.** "A/B testing with 25 auto-tracked KPIs" ([product page](https://stay.ai/product/)). A test can cover "two or more cancel surveys simultaneously" ([help article](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/15484167-a-b-testing-multiple-cancel-surveys)).
- **Failed payments.** Smart Dunning will "retry each failed subscription up to seven times" ([help center](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/6887868-subscriber-billing-how-to-set-up-your-billing-inventory-settings)). Stay's blog gives a higher number. We quote the product doc.
- **AI analytics.** Staylien, "your AI analytics co-pilot" ([stay.ai/staylien](https://stay.ai/staylien/)), and a connector that "brings your subscription data directly into Claude" ([help article](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/15291953-using-the-stay-mcp-connecting-stay-to-claude)).
- **The move.** "Migration could take up to 2 weeks". It starts with "A kick off call with your designated Onboarding Manager" ([stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing)). Stay lists moves from "Recharge Skio Loop Ordergroove Smartrr BOLD WooCommerce" ([migration page](https://stay.ai/platform-migration/)).

**The company.** Stay began in the fall of 2021 as Retextion ([Stay's blog](https://stay.ai/blog/retextion-stay-ai-announcement/)). Its Shopify app launched Jan 11, 2022. Gina Perrelli is co-founder and CEO ([stay.ai/about](https://stay.ai/about/)).

## What do merchants say about Stay AI?

Merchants rate Stay AI 4.9 stars from 148 App Store reviews, and most praise is about people: onboarding, migration and support. Elsewhere we found interest and vendor-reported results, few first-hand merchant posts, and no complaints.

**App Store** (all 148 reviews read Nov 17, 2026, [listing](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions/reviews?sort_by=newest)). 145 are five stars, 1 is four, 1 is three and 1 is one. About 120 mention support, the team, a success manager or onboarding. 44 of the 148 were left within two months of install, so those speak most to the move. Reviewers wrote:

- "Stay AI is by far the best one." ([Electro, Sep 25, 2026](https://apps.shopify.com/reviews/2373821))
- "I moved over from Recharge to Stay.ai a few years ago and have never looked back." ([Rootless, Jul 6, 2026](https://apps.shopify.com/reviews/2273981))
- "it's worth every penny!" ([Megababe, Feb 16, 2026](https://apps.shopify.com/reviews/2083598))

**The reviews below five stars.** The 3-star and 1-star reviews fault promises from the sales team.

- **3 stars, Rootless Coffee Company, Jun 13, 2026:** "another case of overpromising and underdelivering." It says promised meetings with its success manager didn't happen, but "The platform itself is solid. It works as advertised" ([review](https://apps.shopify.com/reviews/2243646)). The listing shows "Rootless" and "Rootless Coffee Company" as two stores.
- **1 star, ShopSketchBox, Aug 15, 2023:** the team promised a project, then said its system "couldn't properly handle flat rate bundles". "Sales shouldn't make promises." Stay's CEO replied: "we were not a great fit for Sketchbox's needs" ([review](https://apps.shopify.com/reviews/1155581)).
- **4 stars, Willow Boutique, Jan 14, 2025:** "we had to jump through some hoops with Stay AI but in the end we were able to create something unique and new to the subscription world!" ([review](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions/reviews?ratings%5B%5D=4)).

**On X** (posts gathered Nov 16, 2026). 11 of the 186 posts we gathered touched Stay AI, and most of those were integrations or promotion from vendors. In a poll on "Skio, Recharge, or StayAI?" ([Julia Pérez, Sep 23, 2026](https://x.com/JuliaPerezzz/status/2102844439500877854)), replies gave Skio 6 votes, Loop 4, Recharge 2 and Stay AI 1. Stay's vote came from a self-declared "Obviously biased" voter ([Steve O'Dell](https://x.com/sodellicious/status/2102960243751755864)). Julia replied to him: "We are leaning this way for sure" ([Julia Pérez, Sep 23, 2026](https://x.com/JuliaPerezzz/status/2102960530289733859)). A founder wrote: "Liking Skio rn but I am checking out StayAi as well" ([Bruce Rhodes, Sep 24, 2026](https://x.com/Brucerhodess/status/2103186722762936409)).

No merchant post we found discusses Stay's price or contract.

## Is Stay AI independent now that Recharge owns Skio?

Yes, as far as we can find. Recharge bought Skio in April 2026. We found no sale of Stay AI, and Stay calls itself independent.

Recharge announced on Apr 30, 2026 that "Skio is joining the company" ([PR Newswire](https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/recharge-welcomes-skio-to-build-the-future-of-subscription-commerce-302759194.html)). TechCrunch reported the same day that Skio "has been acquired by competitor Recharge" ([TechCrunch](https://techcrunch.com/2026/04/30/y-combinator-alum-skio-sells-for-105m-cash-only-raised-8m-founder-says/)). Stay's Nov 13, 2026 comparison lists itself as "Independent" ([Stay's blog](https://stay.ai/blog/recharge-vs-skio-vs-stay-ai/)).

**Size.** Stay says it serves "500+ brands" ([compare page](https://stay.ai/stay-vs-recharge/)). Store Leads counts 942 stores with Stay AI installed ([Store Leads](https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/stayai-subscriptions)), 1,714 with Skio ([Store Leads](https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/skio)) and 4,487 with Loop ([Store Leads](https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/loop-subscriptions)), all updated Nov 13, 2026. Installs are not revenue, and Store Leads' report pages don't explain its method.

## Is Stay AI worth it, and who does it suit?

Stay AI is worth a look for brands above about $343k a year in subscription revenue that would otherwise pick Recharge or Skio. From there up it costs less than both at list price, with a move done for you and an account manager.

*Yearly cost by subscription revenue: Stay AI, Recharge, Skio and Loop. List prices as of Nov 17, 2026, $40 average order, before payment processing.*

| Yearly revenue | Stay AI ($299, annual contract) | Recharge (Starter) | Skio (Scale, billed yearly) | Loop (Starter, no per-order fee) |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|
| $50k | $4,325.50 | $2,788 | $6,863 | $1,688 |
| $100k | $5,063 | $3,788 | $7,738 | $2,188 |
| $250k | $7,275.50 | $6,788 | $10,363 | $3,688 |
| $342,857 (Stay = Recharge) | $8,645.14 | $8,645.14 | $11,988 | $4,616.57 |
| $500k | $10,963 | $11,788 | $14,738 | $6,188 |
| $1M | $18,338 | $21,788 | $23,488 | $11,188 |

*List prices, $40 average order, before payment processing. Loop shown with no per-order fee; with its 15¢ "loyalty order" fee on every order, Loop Starter costs $1,875.50 at $50k and $8,063 at $500k, still below Stay. Recharge, Skio, Loop and Stay all sell custom plans at volume. Sources: each app's pricing page, read Nov 17, 2026.*

- **Under $100k a year:** the $3,588 fixed fee alone is 3.6% of revenue at $100k and 7.2% at $50k, and more below that. Shopify Subscriptions is free.
- **$100k to $343k:** Recharge Starter costs less than Stay below $342,857. On Stay's $499 no-contract price, if the same 1% + 19¢ applies, Recharge Starter costs less up to $800,000.
- **$343k and up:** Stay costs less than Recharge and Skio ($29,900 a year less at $10M). High Growth is custom, so ask for a quote.

**Strong:**

- A lower rate than Recharge and Skio.
- A free move with an onboarding manager.
- An account manager on every plan.
- A/B tests on cancel surveys and offers.
- 4.9 stars.

**Weak:**

- A percentage plus 19¢, with no published fee base.
- Two pages that differ on the contract.
- Many reviews come early: 44 of 148 were left within two months of install. We did not count this for the other apps.

## What are the best Stay AI alternatives at my size?

The best alternative depends on your size. Under $343k a year, Recharge Starter costs less than Stay. At every published size, Loop, Appstle, Seal, Shopify Subscriptions and OpenSubs cost less.

*Stay AI and its alternatives: list price, terms and yearly cost by subscription revenue. As of Nov 17, 2026, $40 average order, before payment processing.*

| App (plan used) | List price | How it bills | Who runs the move | Yearly cost at $250k | Yearly cost at $1M | App Store rating |
|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|
| [Stay AI](https://stay.ai/pricing) (Standard) | $299 a month + 1% + 19¢ a transaction; $499 a month with no contract; High Growth custom | Annual contract on stay.ai; "Monthly Plan" with a 30-day trial on the App Store | Stay's team, "no implementation charge" | $7,275.50 | $18,338 | 4.9 (148) |
| [Loop](https://www.loopwork.co/pricing) | Free to 50 subscriptions; Starter $99 a month + 1%; Pro $399 + 0.75%; Enterprise custom² | Month to month, 14-day trial | Loop's team, on every paid plan | $3,688 (Starter) | $11,188 (Starter) | 4.9 (817) |
| [Recharge](https://getrecharge.com/pricing/) | Starter $149 a month + 1.50% + 20¢; Scale $499 + 1.25% + 20¢; Custom | Starter monthly, 60-day trial | Recharge, listed under Scale | $6,788 (Starter) | $21,788 (Starter) | 4.8 (3,160) |
| [Skio](https://skio.com/pricing) (Scale, billed yearly) | $499 a month + 1.25% + 20¢; $599 billed monthly; Enterprise custom | Yearly or monthly | Skio's team, "No migration fees" | $10,363 | $23,488 | 5.0 (247) |
| [Appstle](https://appstle.com/products/appstle-subscriptions-pricing/) | Free to $500 a month in revenue, then $10 to $300 a month by band; 0% and $0 an order | Monthly or yearly (save 20%), 14-day trial | Appstle's team, every plan | $1,200 (Business Premium) | $1,200 (Business Premium) | 5.0 (9,292) |
| [Seal Subscriptions](https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/pricing) | Free to 50 subscriptions, then $5.95 to $399 a month by subscription count; 0% and $0 an order | Monthly or yearly (save 20%), 30-day trial | You, with Seal's free tools and support | $1,079.40 (Leader) | $2,388 (Mega Star) | 4.9 (3,175) |
| [Shopify Subscriptions](https://apps.shopify.com/shopify-subscriptions) | Free; 0% and $0 an order | None | You, by CSV import | $0 | $0 | 3.8 (910) |
| OpenSubs (we make it) | $0 with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year); 0% and $0 an order¹ | Membership, monthly | You, with OpenSubs' migration tool | $2,388 | $2,388 | Not on the App Store |

¹ Plus about $45 a month for hosting on your own accounts. With hosting, about $2,928 a year.
² Loop's plan cards add 15¢ (Starter) or 10¢ (Pro) per "loyalty order". Counted on every order, Loop costs $4,625.50 at $250k (Starter) and $14,788 at $1M (Pro). Ask Loop which orders count.

Stay AI, Recharge, Skio, Loop, Appstle and Seal all sell custom plans at volume, so a large brand may pay less than list. Ratings are from each app's Shopify App Store listing, read Nov 17, 2026.

*Yearly saving if a Stay AI store moves (best-fit published plan. A negative number means it costs more.). List prices as of Nov 17, 2026, $40 average order.*

| Alternative (plan used) | $250k a year | $1M a year | $5M a year |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Stay AI, $299 annual (what you pay now) | $7,275.50 | $18,338 | $77,338 |
| [Loop](https://www.loopwork.co/pricing)² | $3,587.50 (Starter) | $7,150 (Starter) | $35,050 (Pro) |
| [Recharge](https://getrecharge.com/pricing/) | $487.50 (Starter) | −$3,450 (Starter) | −$16,150 (Scale) |
| [Skio](https://skio.com/pricing) (billed yearly) | −$3,087.50 | −$5,150 | −$16,150 |
| [Appstle](https://appstle.com/products/appstle-subscriptions-pricing/) | $6,075.50 | $17,138 | $73,738 |
| [Seal Subscriptions](https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/pricing) | $6,196.10 | $15,950 | $74,950 |
| [Shopify Subscriptions](https://apps.shopify.com/shopify-subscriptions) | $7,275.50 | $18,338 | $77,338 |
| OpenSubs: $0 with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year)¹ | $4,887.50 | $15,950 | $74,950 |

¹ Plus about $45 a month for hosting on your own accounts. With hosting, the saving is $4,347.50, $15,410 and $74,410.
² With no per-order fee. Loop's plan cards add 15¢ (Starter) or 10¢ (Pro) per "loyalty order". Counted on every order, the saving is $2,650, $3,550 and $22,550. Ask Loop which orders count.

On the $499 price, add $2,400 to every saving. Weigh fee savings against Stay's free move and account manager. Our [guide to Shopify subscription apps](/blog/best-shopify-subscription-apps) covers every size.

Each app below as of Nov 17, 2026: prices and terms from its own pricing page, ratings from its Shopify App Store listing.

### Loop

Best for retention tools and a free move, month to month. It is free up to 50 active subscriptions. Starter is $99 a month + 1%, Pro is $399 + 0.75%, and Enterprise is custom ([loopwork.co/pricing](https://www.loopwork.co/pricing)). "White-glove migration is included on every paid plan." It has a 14-day trial and 4.9 stars from 817 reviews.

Limit: a percentage, plus a "loyalty order" fee it doesn't define.

Read more: [Loop Subscriptions: pricing, reviews and alternatives](/blog/loop-subscriptions-pricing-and-alternatives)

### Recharge

Best for brands that want the most-installed subscription app (49,946 stores, [Store Leads](https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/subscription-payments), updated Nov 13, 2026) and a 60-day trial. Below $342,857 a year, Starter costs less than Stay. Starter is $149 a month + 1.50% + 20¢, month to month, with a 60-day trial. Scale is $499 + 1.25% + 20¢, and Custom is on request ([getrecharge.com/pricing](https://getrecharge.com/pricing/)). Reviews praise "excellent human support" (Shopify summary). It has 4.8 stars from 3,160 reviews. Recharge has owned Skio since April 2026.

Limit: the fee also covers one-time orders, shipping, tax and refunded orders. See [Recharge pricing](/blog/recharge-pricing).

### Skio

Best for retention-first brands that want Skio's team. Scale is $499 a month billed yearly or $599 monthly, plus 1.25% + 20¢ on orders that include a subscription. Enterprise is custom ([skio.com/pricing](https://skio.com/pricing)). "No setup fees. No migration fees." It has 5.0 stars from 247 reviews.

Limit: the highest list cost here, tied with Recharge Scale above $1.68M. When an order includes any subscription product, the fee covers the whole order, one-time items, shipping and tax included ([Skio Help Center](https://help.skio.com/help/docs/reading-and-understanding-skio-billing)). See [Skio pricing and alternatives](/blog/skio-pricing-and-alternatives).

### Appstle

Best for stores up to $6M a year that want 0% and a move done for them. It is free up to $500 a month in revenue, then $10 to $300 a month by band, and custom above $500k a month. Yearly billing saves 20% ([Appstle pricing](https://appstle.com/products/appstle-subscriptions-pricing/)). "The Appstle team moves your existing subscriptions over for you" on every plan ([Appstle help center](https://help.appstle.com/en/articles/11404745-migrate-to-appstle-subscriptions-from-another-app)). 5.0 stars from 9,292 reviews.

Limit: cancel offers start on the $30 plan.

### Seal Subscriptions

Best for stores on a budget at any size. It is free up to 50 subscriptions, then from $5.95 a month. Mega Star is $199 a month for up to 50,000 subscriptions. It takes 0% of revenue, and yearly billing saves 20% ([sealsubscriptions.com/pricing](https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/pricing)). Shopify's review summary says merchants find it "reliable at scale and strong value for money". It has 4.9 stars from 3,175 reviews.

Limit: you run the import yourself, though Seal says "Migration is free. Support is included." ([Seal](https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/migrate-from-recharge)). See [Seal vs Appstle vs OpenSubs](/blog/seal-vs-appstle-vs-opensubs).

### Shopify Subscriptions

The free baseline: 0% of revenue and $0 an order ([listing](https://apps.shopify.com/shopify-subscriptions)). It is Shopify's own app. Customers can "resume, skip, or cancel their subscriptions" ([Help Center](https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/products/purchase-options/subscriptions/shopify-subscriptions)).

Limit: no cancel flow or save offers listed, you import by CSV yourself, and 3.8 stars from 910 reviews.

Read more: [Is the free Shopify Subscriptions app enough?](/blog/shopify-subscriptions-app)

### OpenSubs (we make it)

OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Membership also gives you Open Email, the Insiders Mac app, an agency on request for design, code, ads, email and copy, a community of Shopify brand owners, and a marketplace of approved vendors. That is $2,388 a year, with 0% of revenue and $0 an order. Its migration tool knows Stay's export on sight. OpenSubs is source-available. See the hosting note under the table.

Limit: you migrate yourself. Seal costs less at smaller sizes ($1,079.40 a year at $250k) and the same on Mega Star (less billed yearly), Appstle costs less below $1.2M, and Shopify Subscriptions is free. OpenSubs has no App Store rating and few public reviews.

## What moves if you leave Stay AI?

Your subscription list exports to a CSV, and the new app must match each subscriber to a card saved with Shopify. Check your contract first.

1. **Your term.** On the annual contract, check the end date and exit terms.
2. **Export.** "Clicking Export to CSV will allow you to export a list of subscriptions and their individual line items to an email address of your choice" ([Stay help center](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/11940523-subscription-management-in-the-merchant-portal)).
3. **Cards.** Stay's help center said on Apr 9, 2026 that from May 4, 2026, "Shopify will revoke a customer's payment method from a cancelled subscription", for all Shopify subscription apps ([help article](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/14443359-faq-shopify-payment-method-change-on-cancelled-subscriptions)). Ask your new app how it moves live subscriptions without canceling them first.
4. **Who moves you** (as of Nov 17, 2026). Loop, Skio and Appstle do it at no charge. Recharge lists migration support under Scale. Seal's migration is free with support, but you run the import. With Shopify Subscriptions and OpenSubs, you run it.

## FAQ

### How much does Stay AI cost?

Stay AI costs $299 a month plus 1% + 19¢ per transaction. Stay's pricing page ties the $299 to an annual contract and lists $499 a month with no contract. Its App Store listing sells the $299 as a monthly plan with a 30-day trial. At a $40 average order, Standard costs $18,338 a year at $1M in subscription revenue ([stay.ai/pricing](https://stay.ai/pricing), [App Store listing](https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions), as of Nov 17, 2026).

### Does Stay AI need an annual contract?

Stay's pages differ (as of Nov 17, 2026). The pricing page ties $299 to an "annual contract". The App Store listing sells it as a "Monthly Plan". Ask Stay which applies, and get it in writing.

### Does Stay AI have a free trial?

As of Nov 17, 2026, the App Store listing shows a 30-day free trial on the $299 Monthly Plan, and Stay's pricing page shows none. It showed a "30-Day Free Trial" in 2025 ([Wayback, Jun 15, 2025](https://web.archive.org/web/20250615203334/https://stay.ai/pricing/)).

### Is Stay AI legit?

Yes. Stay AI launched on the Shopify App Store on Jan 11, 2022 and holds 4.9 stars from 148 reviews (Nov 17, 2026). TechCrunch reported its funding in Jul 2023 ([TechCrunch](https://techcrunch.com/2023/07/25/stay-ai-shopify-brands-customer-retention/)).

### Is Stay AI worth it for Shopify subscriptions?

It can be for brands above about $343k a year in subscription revenue that would otherwise pick Recharge or Skio. From there it costs less than both at list price (as of Nov 17, 2026), with a free move and an account manager. On Stay's $499 no-contract price, if the same 1% + 19¢ applies, it costs less than Recharge Starter only above $800,000. Loop, Appstle, Seal, OpenSubs and the free Shopify Subscriptions app cost less at every published size.

### Recharge vs Skio vs Loop vs Stay AI: which should a Shopify brand pick?

At $1M a year in subscription revenue and a $40 average order (as of Nov 17, 2026):

- **Loop:** $11,188 (Starter), the lowest. It is $14,788 (Pro) if the "loyalty order" fee hits every order.
- **Stay AI:** $18,338 (annual contract), with a free move and an account manager.
- **Recharge:** $21,788 (Starter), with a 60-day trial.
- **Skio:** $23,488 (billed yearly), 5.0 stars, owned by Recharge.

Shopify Subscriptions is free, and Appstle, Seal and OpenSubs take 0% of revenue. More on [Recharge](/blog/recharge-pricing) and [Skio](/blog/skio-pricing-and-alternatives).

### What is the best Stay AI alternative?

At list prices as of Nov 17, 2026: under $343k a year, Recharge Starter, Loop, Appstle, Seal or Shopify Subscriptions. Above that, Loop for a lower percentage with a free move, or Appstle (up to $6M a year), Seal or OpenSubs for 0% of revenue.

### Will customers re-enter cards if I leave Stay AI?

Not if the new app matches each subscriber to the card already saved with Shopify. Ask your new app to show every row matched before you switch. Don't cancel live subscriptions first: Stay's help center says that from May 4, 2026, Shopify revokes the payment method on a canceled subscription ([Stay help center](https://help.stay.ai/en/articles/14443359-faq-shopify-payment-method-change-on-cancelled-subscriptions)).

## Sources, method and change log

**Method.** Yearly cost = monthly fee × 12 + revenue × percentage + (revenue ÷ $40) × per-order fee. We treat all revenue as subscription orders, at a $40 average order. Each app is on its cheapest published plan for that size.

We show Stay AI on its annual contract and Skio billed yearly, because their pricing pages lead with those prices. Notes give the other options. We show Loop with no per-order fee, with the "loyalty order" case in a note, and Seal at one order per subscription a month. List prices in USD, before payment processing, loyalty add-ons and SMS. We did not run a live store on each app.

**Sources, all read Nov 17, 2026 unless noted.**

*Stay AI*
- Pricing and FAQ: https://stay.ai/pricing
- App Store listing and reviews: https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions
- Compare page: https://stay.ai/stay-vs-recharge/
- Blog, Nov 13, 2026: https://stay.ai/blog/recharge-vs-skio-vs-stay-ai/
- Product pages: https://stay.ai/product/ · https://stay.ai/product/churn-prevention/ · https://stay.ai/staylien/ · https://stay.ai/platform-migration/
- Help center articles (billing settings, A/B tests, MCP, export, payment-method change): links in the text
- Company: https://stay.ai/about/ · https://stay.ai/blog/retextion-stay-ai-announcement/
- Archived pages (Wayback Machine): stay.ai/pricing on Feb 7, 2023, Jul 16, 2024, Jun 15, 2025 and Oct 10, 2026. Links in the text.

*Outside reports*
- TechCrunch, Christine Hall, Jul 25, 2023: https://techcrunch.com/2023/07/25/stay-ai-shopify-brands-customer-retention/
- RetainUP, "Stay AI Review 2026", updated Nov 13, 2026 (agency): https://retainup.co/stay-ai-retention-setup/
- Store Leads, updated Nov 13, 2026: https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/stayai-subscriptions · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/skio · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/loop-subscriptions · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/subscription-payments
- Recharge press release, Apr 30, 2026: https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/recharge-welcomes-skio-to-build-the-future-of-subscription-commerce-302759194.html
- TechCrunch, Apr 30, 2026: https://techcrunch.com/2026/04/30/y-combinator-alum-skio-sells-for-105m-cash-only-raised-8m-founder-says/

*Alternatives*
- Recharge: https://getrecharge.com/pricing/ · https://support.getrecharge.com/hc/en-us/articles/360008682914-Recharge-billing-and-pricing · https://apps.shopify.com/subscription-payments
- Skio: https://skio.com/pricing · https://help.skio.com/help/docs/reading-and-understanding-skio-billing · https://apps.shopify.com/skio
- Loop: https://www.loopwork.co/pricing · https://apps.shopify.com/loop-subscriptions
- Appstle: https://appstle.com/products/appstle-subscriptions-pricing/ · https://help.appstle.com/en/articles/11404745-migrate-to-appstle-subscriptions-from-another-app · https://apps.shopify.com/subscriptions-by-appstle
- Seal: https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/pricing · https://www.sealsubscriptions.com/migrate-from-recharge · https://apps.shopify.com/seal-subscriptions
- Shopify Subscriptions: https://apps.shopify.com/shopify-subscriptions · https://help.shopify.com/en/manual/products/purchase-options/subscriptions/shopify-subscriptions
- OpenSubs: https://opensubs-insider.jd-a12.workers.dev/#pricing

*Community:* App Store reviews read Nov 17, 2026. X posts pulled Nov 16, 2026. Links in the text.

**Change log**
- November 20, 2026: first published. Prices checked against each vendor's page on Nov 17, 2026.

---

## Sources

These are the outside sources this page cites most. Stay AI's own pages and the rival apps' own pages are linked in the text and are not listed here.

1. **Shopify App Store merchant reviews of Stay AI**
   Role: Shopify's public review system, where stores that installed the app rate it.
   Work: all 148 reviews on the Stay AI Subscriptions listing, read Nov 17, 2026: https://apps.shopify.com/stayai-subscriptions/reviews?sort_by=newest
   Why: it is the largest set of first-hand merchant views of Stay AI, including the three reviews below five stars.

2. **Internet Archive, Wayback Machine**
   Role: a nonprofit archive that saves dated copies of web pages.
   Work: copies of stay.ai/pricing from Feb 7, 2023, Jul 16, 2024, Jun 15, 2025 and Oct 10, 2026, for example https://web.archive.org/web/20230207135721/https://stay.ai/pricing/ and https://web.archive.org/web/20261010061057/https://stay.ai/pricing
   Why: it shows how Stay's price, plan names and contract terms changed over time, in Stay's own words.

3. **Rahi Jain, RetainUP**
   Role: Subscription LTV Specialist at RetainUP, an agency that sets up retention programs on Stay AI and other subscription apps.
   Work: "Stay AI Review 2026", Oct 24, 2026, updated Nov 13, 2026: https://retainup.co/stay-ai-retention-setup/
   Why: it is the earliest outside report of the $299 annual and $499 no-contract prices we found, which dates the price change. RetainUP sells Stay AI setup work, so it is not neutral.

4. **Store Leads**
   Role: a data company that tracks which apps Shopify stores have installed.
   Work: app reports for Stay AI, Skio, Loop and Recharge, updated Nov 13, 2026: https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/stayai-subscriptions · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/skio · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/loop-subscriptions · https://storeleads.app/reports/shopify/app/subscription-payments
   Why: it gives an outside count of stores with Stay AI, Skio, Loop and Recharge installed. Its counts are installs, not revenue, and its report pages do not explain its method.

5. **Christine Hall, TechCrunch**
   Role: reporter at TechCrunch, a technology news site.
   Work: "Stay Ai's tech helps Shopify brands get customers to make that second purchase", Jul 25, 2023: https://techcrunch.com/2023/07/25/stay-ai-shopify-brands-customer-retention/
   Why: it is an independent report on Stay AI's funding and its price and merchant count in 2023.

These sources are cited for their published work. None of them is affiliated with OpenSubs.
