This page compares four Shopify subscription options that take 0% of revenue and $0 an order, as of Nov 17, 2026. Shopify Subscriptions is free. Seal Subscriptions and Appstle Subscriptions each have a free plan, then charge flat monthly fees that step up as the store grows. OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Seal's price steps up with the number of subscriptions. Appstle's steps up with monthly subscription revenue.
At 5,000 subscriptions ($200,000 a month at $40 each), Seal Mega Star costs $199 a month and Appstle Enterprise costs $300 a month. OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Smaller stores pay less on Seal and Appstle. Seal Mega Star matches the $199, and it costs less billed yearly.
For the founder's story of why subscription apps charge what they do, read How Shopify subscriptions work: the fee explained.
OpenSubs makes a subscription app. Here is how we checked.
Which Shopify subscription apps take 0% of revenue and $0 an order?
Shopify Subscriptions, Seal Subscriptions, Appstle Subscriptions and OpenSubs all charge 0% of revenue and $0 an order, as of Nov 17, 2026. They differ in what sets the price.
For all eight apps we price, including the ones that charge a percentage of revenue, see the best Shopify subscription apps comparison.
At a glance: the four 0% options compared here, as of Nov 17, 2026. Each cell links to the vendor's own page or App Store listing.
| Shopify Subscriptions | Seal Subscriptions | Appstle Subscriptions | OpenSubs | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| % of revenue | 0% (listing) | 0% (pricing) | 0% (pricing) | 0% |
| Per-order fee | $0 (listing) | $0 (pricing) | $0 (pricing) | $0 |
| Price | Free (listing) | $0 to $399 a month, then custom (pricing) | $0 to $300 a month, then custom (pricing) | $0 with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year)¹ |
| What sets the price | Nothing: the app is free | Number of subscriptions (pricing) | Monthly subscription revenue (help) | Nothing: one membership price at every size |
| Free trial | Not needed | 30 days on every paid plan (pricing) | 14 days on paid plans (listing) | |
| App Store rating | 3.8 from 910 reviews (listing) | 4.9 from 3,175 reviews (listing) | 5.0 from 9,292 reviews (listing) | No App Store listing |
¹ OpenSubs runs on your own hosting accounts. These cost about $45 a month ($540 a year), plus the email and SMS you send. They are not part of the membership. With hosting, OpenSubs is about $2,928 a year.
What does Seal Subscriptions cost?
Seal Subscriptions publishes seven plans, from $0 to $399 a month, plus a custom plan past 150,000 subscriptions, as of Nov 17, 2026 (Seal pricing). Every plan charges 0% of revenue and $0 an order. Billed yearly, every paid plan costs 20% less.
Seal Subscriptions plans, as of Nov 17, 2026 (sealsubscriptions.com/pricing, with the first four also on the App Store listing)
| Plan | Monthly | Billed yearly | Billed yearly, per month | Max subscriptions | Where the price is listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | $0 | $0 | 50 | Seal's site and App Store |
| Supersale | $5.95 | $57.12 | $4.76 | 100 | Seal's site and App Store |
| Rising Star | $9.95 | $95.52 | $7.96 | 250 | Seal's site and App Store |
| Legend | $24.95 | $239.52 | $19.96 | 500 | Seal's site and App Store |
| Leader | $89.95 | $863.52 | $71.96 | 2,000 | Seal's site only |
| Mega Star | $199 | $1,910.40 | $159.20 | 50,000 | Seal's site only |
| Superstar | $399 | $3,830.40 | $319.20 | 150,000 | Seal's site only |
| Custom | Ask Seal | Ask Seal | n/a | Over 150,000 | Seal's site |
What to know about Seal's plans, as of Nov 17, 2026:
- Seal caps subscriptions, not revenue. Each plan card on its App Store listing says revenue is unlimited. The plan cards on its own pricing page count "total subscriptions". Past 50 on the free plan, you move to a paid plan (Seal FAQ).
- A subscription is one delivery interval in an order. If a customer subscribes to product A weekly and product B monthly in one order, Seal "will split this order in two subscriptions". Products and subscription rules have no limit (Seal FAQ).
What does Appstle Subscriptions cost?
Appstle Subscriptions has five priced plans, from $0 to $300 a month, as of Nov 17, 2026 (Appstle pricing). It also has a custom Enterprise Plus plan for stores past $500,000 a month in subscription revenue. Every plan card shows a 0% transaction fee, and no plan charges per order. Billed yearly, every paid plan costs 20% less.
Appstle Subscriptions plans, as of Nov 17, 2026 (Appstle pricing, with the first four also on the App Store listing)
| Plan | Monthly | Billed yearly | Billed yearly, per month | Monthly subscription revenue | Where the price is listed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | $0 | $0 | Up to $500 | Appstle's site and App Store |
| Starter | $10 | $96 | $8 | Up to $5,000 | Appstle's site and App Store |
| Business | $30 | $288 | $24 | Up to $15,000 | Appstle's site and App Store |
| Business Premium | $100 | $960 | $80 | Up to $100,000 | Appstle's site and App Store |
| Enterprise | $300 | $2,880 | $240 | Up to $500,000 | Appstle's site only |
| Enterprise Plus | Custom | Custom | n/a | Over $500,000 | Appstle's site |
What to know about Appstle's plans, as of Nov 17, 2026:
- The band counts new subscriptions too, not only renewals. Appstle measures a month's figure as the total recurring order amount plus the total subscribed amount (Appstle help center). So a month's new subscription sales count toward the band. A store near a cap may reach the next plan sooner than its renewals alone suggest.
What does OpenSubs cost?
OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year). It takes 0% of revenue and $0 an order. The price does not step up with subscriptions or revenue, and there is no yearly price. The OpenSubs home page puts it as "Subscriptions for Shopify at 0% and $0 an order."
Every comparison below uses $2,388 a year for OpenSubs, because that is what a merchant pays.
What share of revenue does each plan work out to?
Past a few thousand subscriptions, every option here costs a small fraction of a percent of revenue. At 10,000 subscriptions ($400,000 a month at $40), Appstle Enterprise is 0.075% of revenue, Seal Mega Star 0.050% and Insider membership ($199 a month, OpenSubs included) 0.050%. The shares differ most at small stores. At 500 subscriptions, Appstle is 0.500%, Seal 0.125% and the membership 0.995%.
The math: share = monthly price ÷ monthly subscription revenue. Example: Seal Leader at 501 subscriptions is $89.95 ÷ (501 × $40) = $89.95 ÷ $20,040 = 0.45%.
Price as a share of revenue at the same store, as of Nov 17, 2026. Each subscription bills $40 once a month. Monthly billing. Best-fit plan: the cheapest published plan that fits. Prices from Seal pricing and Appstle pricing.
| Subscriptions | Monthly revenue | Appstle (best-fit plan) | Seal (best-fit plan) | OpenSubs (membership, $199)¹ | Shopify Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 50 | $2,000 | Starter $10: 10 ÷ 2,000 = 0.500% | Free $0: 0% | 199 ÷ 2,000 = 9.950% | 0% |
| 100 | $4,000 | Starter $10: 0.250% | Supersale $5.95: 5.95 ÷ 4,000 = 0.149% | 4.975% | 0% |
| 250 | $10,000 | Business $30: 0.300% | Rising Star $9.95: 0.100% | 1.990% | 0% |
| 500 | $20,000 | Business Premium $100: 0.500% | Legend $24.95: 0.125% | 0.995% | 0% |
| 1,000 | $40,000 | Business Premium $100: 0.250% | Leader $89.95: 0.225% | 0.498% | 0% |
| 2,000 | $80,000 | Business Premium $100: 0.125% | Leader $89.95: 0.112% | 0.249% | 0% |
| 5,000 | $200,000 | Enterprise $300: 0.150% | Mega Star $199: 0.100% | 0.100% | 0% |
| 10,000 | $400,000 | Enterprise $300: 0.075% | Mega Star $199: 0.050% | 0.050% | 0% |
| 25,000 | $1,000,000 | Custom (Enterprise Plus) | Mega Star $199: 0.020% | 0.020% | 0% |
| 50,000 | $2,000,000 | Custom | Mega Star $199: 0.010% | 0.010% | 0% |
| 100,000 | $4,000,000 | Custom | Superstar $399: 0.010% | 0.005% | 0% |
| 150,000 | $6,000,000 | Custom | Superstar $399: 0.007% | 0.003% | 0% |
¹ OpenSubs runs on your own hosting accounts, about $45 a month, plus the email and SMS you send. With hosting (about $244 a month), multiply the OpenSubs share by 1.226.
Billed yearly, Seal and Appstle take 20% off, so their shares drop by a fifth. The membership has no yearly price.
For how a renewal runs on Shopify, and why some apps charge a percentage while these do not, see how Shopify recurring payments work.
The highest share each app reaches at any size, on monthly billing: Appstle 2.0% (Starter, just over $500 a month) and Seal 0.45% (Leader, at 501 subscriptions). Above $15,000 a month in subscription revenue, Appstle never passes 0.67%. Above $80,000 a month, Seal never passes 0.25%, on the $40 assumption.
If your subscriptions bill less than $40 a month, or less often than monthly, every share in the table rises, because the same number of subscriptions brings in less revenue. On Seal it can also move your plan: Seal prices by count, so you reach each cap at less revenue. Two more things can push Seal higher. Orders with two delivery intervals count as two subscriptions, and Seal does not say if canceled subscriptions count toward the cap. On Appstle, a month's new subscribed amounts count toward the band as well as renewals.
Which is cheapest at my store size?
Shopify Subscriptions is cheapest at every size, at $0. Among the paid options, Seal or Appstle costs less than Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year), which includes OpenSubs, up to about $1.2M a year in subscription revenue. Seal Mega Star and OpenSubs then cost the same $2,388 a year on monthly billing up to 50,000 subscriptions. Billed yearly, Mega Star costs less. Past 50,000 subscriptions, OpenSubs costs less than Seal Superstar. All figures are as of Nov 17, 2026, at a $40 subscription billed once a month.
Yearly cost by yearly subscription revenue, monthly billing, as of Nov 17, 2026. Each subscription bills $40 once a month. Best-fit plan: the cheapest published plan that fits. Prices from Seal pricing and Appstle pricing.
| Yearly subscription revenue | Subscriptions (about) | Seal (plan) | Appstle (plan) | OpenSubs (membership)¹ | Shopify Subscriptions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50k | 104 | $119.40 (Rising Star) | $120 (Starter) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $100k | 208 | $119.40 (Rising Star) | $360 (Business) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $250k | 521 | $1,079.40 (Leader) | $1,200 (Business Premium) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $500k | 1,042 | $1,079.40 (Leader) | $1,200 (Business Premium) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $1M | 2,083 | $2,388 (Mega Star) | $1,200 (Business Premium) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $2M | 4,167 | $2,388 (Mega Star) | $3,600 (Enterprise) | $2,388 | $0 |
| $5M | 10,417 | $2,388 (Mega Star) | $3,600 (Enterprise) | $2,388 | $0 |
¹ OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year). It runs on your own hosting accounts, about $45 a month ($540 a year), plus the email and SMS you send. With hosting, about $2,928 a year.
Billed yearly, Seal and Appstle take 20% off: Seal $95.52, $863.52 and $1,910.40; Appstle $96, $288, $960 and $2,880. The membership has no yearly price.
Arithmetic: Seal 9.95 × 12 = 119.40; 89.95 × 12 = 1,079.40; 199 × 12 = 2,388. Appstle 10 × 12 = 120; 30 × 12 = 360; 100 × 12 = 1,200; 300 × 12 = 3,600. OpenSubs 199 × 12 = 2,388.
At $200,000 a month, Appstle's plan is Enterprise, $300.
For what a percentage-based app costs at the same sizes, see Skio pricing and alternatives.
Where do Seal and Appstle beat OpenSubs?
Seal and Appstle beat OpenSubs on price for most stores, on reviews, and on migration help. In order, as of Nov 17, 2026:
- They cost less for small and mid-size stores. Up to 2,000 subscriptions (about $960,000 a year at $40), Seal's paid plans cost $71.40 to $1,079.40 a year and Appstle's $120 to $1,200, against $2,388 for the membership. Shopify Subscriptions is free at every size (Seal pricing, Appstle pricing, Shopify listing).
- Seal Mega Star costs the same $199 a month, and less billed yearly. It covers up to 50,000 subscriptions, about $24M a year at $40 a month. Billed yearly it is $1,910.40 (199 × 12 × 0.8), which is $477.60 a year less than the membership's $2,388 (Seal pricing).²
- Thousands of reviews and Shopify's badge. Appstle has 5.0 stars from 9,292 reviews and Seal 4.9 from 3,175. Both carry Shopify's Built for Shopify badge (Appstle listing, Seal listing). OpenSubs has no App Store listing, so it has no rating or review count.
- Appstle moves your subscriptions for you, free, on every plan. Its help center says "the Appstle team moves your existing subscriptions over for you" (Appstle help center). Its migration FAQ says a standard migration takes 24 to 48 hours and is free for all merchants (Appstle FAQ). Seal's migration is free too, with support included (Seal: migrate from Recharge). With OpenSubs, you run the migration yourself.
² OpenSubs also runs on your own hosting accounts, about $45 a month, plus the email and SMS you send. With that added (about $2,928 a year), Seal Mega Star costs $540 less on monthly billing and $1,017.60 less billed yearly. Appstle Enterprise billed yearly ($2,880) costs $48 a year less than OpenSubs.
What does the $199 buy with OpenSubs that the others do not include?
The $199 is a membership, and OpenSubs is one part of it. OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Membership also gives you:
- Open Email
- The Insiders Mac app
- An agency on request for design, code, ads, email and copy
- A community of Shopify brand owners
- A marketplace of approved vendors
Seal's and Appstle's prices buy a subscription app. As of Nov 17, 2026, these are the nearest extras on their pricing pages. Seal has a dedicated success manager on Mega Star (Seal pricing). Appstle has custom development and a dedicated success manager on Enterprise Plus, which is custom priced (Appstle pricing).
The $199 also buys a price shape: 0% of revenue and $0 an order, at one price that does not step. On list price, OpenSubs is cheaper than Appstle only between $1.2M and $6M a year in subscription revenue. It is cheaper than Seal only past 50,000 subscriptions.
Feature by feature
Every option here has a customer portal and failed-payment retries. They differ in which plan carries each feature, what happens by default, and who does the migration.
Features each app states on its own pages, and the plan that carries each, as of Nov 17, 2026. Each cell links to its source.
| Feature | Shopify Subscriptions | Seal Subscriptions | Appstle Subscriptions | OpenSubs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Customer portal | Customers resume, skip or cancel, and manage payment methods and shipping address (Help Center) | Portal settings on every plan, Free included (pricing) | Subscriber portal on every plan, Free included (pricing) | Loads inside your theme, on your domain |
| Cancel flow and save offers | Customers can cancel; no cancel flow or save offers listed (listing) | Cancellation flow from Rising Star, $9.95; cancellation treatments from Mega Star, $199 (pricing) | Cancellation tools and discount offers from Business, $30; targeted flows from Business Premium, $100 (pricing). New stores start on one-click cancel until you switch (help) | Twelve cancel reasons; incentives with a 60-day default cooldown (page) |
| Failed-payment recovery | You set the number of retries and the gap between them (Help Center) | Dunning settings on every plan, Free included (pricing) | Recovery on every plan, Free included; phased retry, retry when the card is updated, and backup card from Business Premium, $100 (help) | Runs by default from day one (page) |
| Default for a new store | Not stated on the pages we read | You set the retry count; the default is not stated (FAQ) | 8 payment attempts in all (the first charge plus 7 retries), 1 day apart, then skip the order and keep the subscription (help) | A failure notice, three retries three days apart, then the ending you pick (page) |
| Who does the migration | You, by CSV import (Help Center) | You, with Seal's Recharge wizard, CSV bulk import or by hand (FAQ); free, support included (Seal: migrate from Recharge) | Appstle's team, free, every plan (help) | You, with OpenSubs' migration tool |
| Support | Not compared | Email and in-app form within 24 hours on workdays, and WhatsApp calls on workdays from 9:00 to 15:00 Central European time; no live chat in the app (FAQ). Priority support on Legend and Leader; priority and phone support on Mega Star (pricing) | 24/7 human support on every plan (listing), by chat in the app (help center) | Through Insider membership: an agency on request and a community of Shopify brand owners |
| API and webhooks | Not compared | Every plan (listing) | Enterprise, $300, and up on Appstle's table (pricing); its listing says to contact Appstle about APIs and webhooks (listing) | Not listed on the pages we read |
What do merchants say?
Merchants rate both Seal and Appstle highly on the Shopify App Store, and praise their price and support. OpenSubs has no App Store listing and no public reviews.
App Store ratings, read Nov 17, 2026
| App | Rating | Reviews | Five-star | One-star | Built for Shopify | On the App Store since | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appstle Subscriptions | 5.0 | 9,292 | 98% | 41 | Yes | Apr 8, 2021 | listing |
| Seal Subscriptions | 4.9 | 3,175 | 93% | 17 | Yes | Mar 18, 2020 | listing |
| Shopify Subscriptions | 3.8 | 910 | 48% | 167 | No | Jan 31, 2024 | listing |
| OpenSubs | No listing | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
The Seal and Appstle listings also carry a summary written by Shopify Magic, Shopify's AI. These are Shopify's words, not a reviewer's. For Seal, it says merchants find it "reliable at scale and strong value for money", and that its support is often praised as fast and friendly (Seal listing). For Appstle, it says merchants call it a powerful, affordable core for subscription businesses. It also says many praise its 24/7 live chat support (Appstle listing).
Which should you pick?
Pick by size first, then by the features and help you need. As of Nov 17, 2026, at a $40 subscription billed once a month:
- Up to 50 subscriptions: Shopify Subscriptions or Seal Free, both $0. Appstle's Free plan stops at $500 a month, about 12 subscriptions.
- 51 to 2,000 subscriptions: Shopify Subscriptions if its features are enough ($0), otherwise Seal or Appstle. Seal costs less at every size we priced in this range. Appstle moves you in for free and answers by live chat around the clock.
- 2,001 to 50,000 subscriptions: Seal Mega Star ($199 a month), Appstle (Business Premium to $100,000 a month, then Enterprise at $300 to $500,000 a month, about $6M a year, then custom), or OpenSubs, free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Mega Star costs less billed yearly. Choose OpenSubs here for the rest of the membership, and for a price that stays the same past 50,000 subscriptions.
- Past 50,000 subscriptions (about $24M a year at $40): OpenSubs, free with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year), Seal Superstar ($399 a month, to 150,000), or a custom quote from Seal or Appstle. Appstle is custom priced from $500,000 a month (about $6M a year).
- When not to switch: if you are under 2,000 subscriptions on Seal or Appstle and have the features you need, stay. The membership costs more at that size. If you are on Seal Mega Star billed yearly, the membership costs $477.60 a year more.
See all eight apps, including the ones that charge a percentage, in the best Shopify subscription apps comparison.
FAQ
Does Appstle's free plan charge a fee?
No. Appstle's Free plan is $0 a month with a 0% transaction fee, for up to $500 a month in subscription revenue, as of Nov 17, 2026 (Appstle pricing). When you reach the limit, Appstle shows you the billing section and asks you to upgrade to keep using the dashboard. It does not charge you without your consent (Appstle help center).
Does Seal count canceled subscriptions?
Seal does not say. Ask Seal. As of Nov 17, 2026, its plans cap "total subscriptions". Its FAQ says one order with two delivery intervals counts as two subscriptions (Seal FAQ).
What happens past the top plan?
Past 150,000 subscriptions, Seal asks you to contact it for a custom plan (Seal pricing). Past $500,000 a month in subscription revenue, Appstle's Enterprise Plus plan is custom priced (Appstle pricing). Both facts are as of Nov 17, 2026. OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month) at every size.
Does Appstle move me up a plan on its own?
No. Appstle's help center says it never charges a merchant without consent, as of Nov 17, 2026. When you pass your band, it asks you to upgrade before you can use the dashboard (Appstle help center). Its band counts the month's recurring orders and new subscribed amounts together.
Is Shopify Subscriptions enough?
For simple subscribe and save, often yes. It is free, and customers can resume, skip or cancel and update their payment method and address (Shopify Help Center). You set the retry count and what happens when retries fail (Help Center). It lists no cancel flow or save offers, and it rates 3.8 from 910 reviews, as of Nov 17, 2026 (listing).
Read more: Is the free Shopify Subscriptions app enough?
Seal or Appstle vs Recharge: what is the difference?
Seal and Appstle charge a flat monthly fee with 0% of revenue and $0 an order. Recharge's current plans, and what they cost at your size, are on our Recharge pricing page. Price comes up in reviews. One Appstle reviewer, a US merchant, says Appstle doesn't charge 1% of sales like other apps (review, edited Sep 13, 2024). Both Seal and Appstle offer free migration from Recharge, as of Nov 17, 2026. Seal gives you a wizard and support (Seal: migrate from Recharge, Seal FAQ). Appstle's team does the move (Appstle help center).
Is OpenSubs open source?
No. OpenSubs is source-available, not open source. It is free with Insider membership ($199 a month).
Is there a 0% subscription app for Shopify Plus brands?
Yes. Shopify Subscriptions, Seal, Appstle and OpenSubs all charge 0% of revenue and $0 an order, as of Nov 17, 2026. Appstle says it works with Shopify and Shopify Plus merchants (Appstle merchants page). For a large Plus brand, the price depends on size:
- Seal Mega Star is $199 a month, up to 50,000 subscriptions.
- Appstle Enterprise is $300 a month, up to $500,000 a month in revenue.
- OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month) at any size.
Sources, method and change log
Method. Prices are list prices in US dollars, before Shopify's plan fee and card processing. We read every rival price, plan, rating and feature on the vendor's own pricing page, help center or Shopify App Store listing on Nov 17, 2026. Shares and yearly costs assume each subscription bills $40 once a month: subscriptions = yearly revenue ÷ $40 ÷ 12, and Appstle's band = yearly revenue ÷ 12. We did not run a live store on each app.
Sources. Every rival fact links to the vendor's own pricing page, help center or Shopify App Store listing where it appears, all read Nov 17, 2026. OpenSubs: cancellation saves, self-healing billing.
Change log
- Nov 17, 2026: First version. All prices, plans, ratings and features checked on this date.
Sources
-
Seal Subscriptions, developer of the Seal Subscriptions app for Shopify. Work: Seal Subscriptions pricing, with its Shopify App Store listing and help articles, read Nov 17, 2026. Why: Seal's own pages are the primary record of its plans, subscription caps, features, migration and support terms.
-
Appstle, developer of the Appstle Subscriptions app for Shopify. Work: Appstle Subscriptions pricing, with its Shopify App Store listing and help center, read Nov 17, 2026. Why: Appstle's own pages are the primary record of its revenue bands, features, failed-payment defaults and free migration.
-
Shopify, maker of the free Shopify Subscriptions app and operator of the Shopify App Store. Work: the Shopify Subscriptions listing and the Help Center guide Shopify Subscriptions, read Nov 17, 2026. Why: it sets the free baseline, and its App Store listings carry the ratings, review counts and Shopify Magic summaries the page compares.
-
ESP Water, a US merchant reviewing Appstle on the Shopify App Store. Work: App Store review of Appstle Subscriptions, edited Sep 13, 2024. Why: a merchant's own review that names Appstle's price, and its 0% of sales, against other apps.
Sources are cited and are not affiliated with OpenSubs.

