We took subscriptions to 0%.
Now email.
Unlimited sends. Unlimited subscribers.
Included in the $199 plan.
All posts

How Shopify recurring payments work, and why subscription app fees differ

On Shopify, checkout saves the card and Shopify charges it when the app starts a renewal. App fees run from free to a monthly fee plus 1.5% + 20¢ an order.

OpenSubs publishes this page. We make one of the apps compared here.

Contents

On Shopify, the shopper picks a subscription at Shopify checkout. Shopify saves the payment method and creates a subscription contract. On each renewal date, the subscription app sends Shopify a billing attempt, and Shopify charges the saved payment method and creates the order (Shopify Developer Documentation). Shopify Payments, or your other payment gateway, charges card processing. The app adds its own fee on top. That ranges from nothing on Shopify's free app to a monthly fee plus as much as 1.50% of revenue and 20¢ an order, as of Nov 17, 2026.

For the founder's story of why the percentage exists, read How Shopify subscriptions work: the fee explained. This page is the plain reference beside it. Each step of a renewal links to Shopify's own documentation, and each app's fee comes with the math shown.


OpenSubs makes a subscription app. Every rival price links to the rival's own page, and every step of the renewal links to Shopify's own documentation or Help Center. The method is at the end.


How does a recurring payment work on Shopify?

A recurring payment on Shopify is a renewal charged under a subscription contract. The subscription app decides when to bill. Shopify takes the payment and creates the order. Here are the steps in order, each from Shopify's documentation (read Nov 17, 2026).

  1. You create a selling plan. A selling plan is the subscription offer on a product. Shopify's own example is "Delivery every week, 15% off" (purchase options). You add it to a product as a subscription purchase option (Shopify Help Center).
  2. The shopper subscribes at Shopify checkout. Shopify's checkout "determines charge amounts, payment terms, and payment and shipping methods" (purchase options). Shopify stores the payment method so it can pay for future orders "without requiring the customer to manually go through checkout" (about subscriptions).
  3. Shopify creates the subscription contract. After the purchase, Shopify generates the contract and sends it to the app by webhook (subscription contracts). The contract is the agreement between the customer and you for the recurring purchase (about subscriptions).
  4. On renewal day, the app sends a billing attempt. In Shopify's words, "A subscription is renewed when an app makes a billing attempt" (build a subscription contract). If the customer asked to skip that cycle, the billing attempt can be skipped (billing cycles).
  5. Shopify charges the saved payment method and creates the order. Shopify receives the billing attempt and "creates the transaction and order" (billing cycles). Each successful renewal is a new order.
  6. Shopify tells the app how it went. Each billing attempt starts as pending and ends as successful or failed. A successful attempt creates the order (build a subscription contract). Shopify sends the app a success or failure webhook (subscription contracts). On a failure, the app decides what happens next.

Who holds the customer's card, Shopify or the app?

Shopify does. Its Help Center says customer payment information "is stored securely by Shopify", and that you can't see a customer's full card number once it's entered (Shopify Help Center, read Nov 17, 2026). In Shopify's data, the saved card is a customer payment method that "Stores the payment instrument details and billing information for recurring charges" (CustomerPaymentMethod).

So on a store that sells through Shopify checkout, the app does not keep the card. It works with the contract and asks Shopify to charge the saved payment method. One exception: contracts moved from an older app can keep billing through the old processor, such as Stripe, on that processor's payment tokens (Shopify Help Center). One subscription app maker, Kaching (a vendor), describes its own renewals the same way: "We never touch card data" (@malisauskasLT, Nov 14, 2026).

Does Shopify charge transaction fees on subscription orders?

Not if the customer pays through Shopify Payments. You pay your Shopify plan and Shopify's card processing rate. Shopify adds a third-party transaction fee when another payment provider takes the payment, though PayPal is exempt if Shopify Payments is your main provider. On stores created on or after May 12, 2025, it also charges the fee on any part of an order paid with store credit or a gift card. That fee comes on top of the provider's own processing fee (third-party transaction fees, read Nov 17, 2026). Your subscription app's fee, if it has one, is separate again.

Shopify plans and fees, US, from shopify.com/pricing, as of Nov 17, 2026. Card processing on a $40 renewal uses the standard online rate.

Shopify plan Monthly (billed yearly) Online card rate, Shopify Payments Card processing on a $40 renewal Third-party transaction fee (other gateways) That fee on $40
Basic $39 ($29) 2.9% + 30¢ $1.46 (3.65%) 2% $0.80
Grow $105 ($79) 2.7% + 30¢ $1.38 (3.45%) 1% $0.40
Advanced $399 ($299) 2.5% + 30¢ $1.30 (3.25%) 0.6% $0.24
Plus from $2,300 2.25% + 30¢ $1.20 (3.00%) 0.2% $0.08

Math: $40 × 2.9% = $1.16, plus 30¢, is $1.46. Premium cards (3.5% + 30¢ on Basic) and international cards (1% more) cost more.

Worked example. On Shopify Basic with Shopify Payments and Recharge Starter, a $40 renewal costs $1.46 in card processing plus $0.80 in Recharge fees. That is $2.26 in all, or 5.65% of the order. That is before Recharge's $149 monthly fee and Shopify's plan fee. On an app that charges no percentage and no per-order fee, the same renewal costs $1.46 in card processing, plus the app's flat monthly fee, if it has one.

Why do subscription app fees differ?

Because the apps price different things. Recharge, Skio and Stay AI charge a monthly fee plus a percentage of revenue and a fee per order. Loop charges a monthly fee plus a percentage of revenue. Seal and Appstle charge a flat monthly fee that steps up as you grow. OpenSubs is free with Insider membership ($199 a month). Membership also gives you Open Email, the Insiders Mac app, an agency on request for design, code, ads, email and copy, a community of Shopify brand owners, and a marketplace of approved vendors. Shopify's own app is free.

How each Shopify subscription app charges, list prices as of Nov 17, 2026

App How it charges Monthly fee Share of revenue Per order Source
OpenSubs Free with Insider membership $0 with Insider membership ($199 a month, $2,388 a year)¹ 0% $0 Insider membership
Recharge Monthly fee + % of revenue + per-order fee Starter $149; Scale $499 1.50%; 1.25% 20¢ getrecharge.com/pricing
Skio Monthly fee + % + per-order fee, on orders with a subscription Scale $499 billed yearly, or $599 billed monthly 1.25% 20¢ skio.com/pricing
Stay AI Monthly fee + % + per-order fee Standard $299 on an annual contract² 1% 19¢ stay.ai/pricing
Loop Monthly fee + % of revenue Free up to 50 active subscriptions; Starter $99; Pro $399 1.0%; 0.75% $0³ loopwork.co/pricing
Appstle Flat monthly fee that steps up with monthly subscription revenue $0 to $500 a month in revenue; $10 to $5k; $30 to $15k; $100 to $100k; $300 to $500k; then custom 0% $0 Appstle pricing
Seal Subscriptions Flat monthly fee that steps up with the number of subscriptions $0 to 50 subscriptions; $5.95 to 100; $9.95 to 250; $24.95 to 500; $89.95 to 2,000; $199 to 50,000; $399 to 150,000; then custom 0% $0 sealsubscriptions.com/pricing
Shopify Subscriptions Free $0 0% $0 App Store listing

¹ OpenSubs runs on your own hosting accounts, about $45 a month ($540 a year). Hosting is not part of the membership and not in this figure. ² Stay AI also sells Standard at $499 a month with no contract. Its page states no percentage or per-order fee for that option. Its App Store listing sells the $299 plan as a monthly plan. ³ Loop's FAQ says its paid plans charge "no per-order flat fee". Its plan cards add 15¢ (Starter) or 10¢ (Pro) "per loyalty order". Ask Loop which orders count.

Seal and Appstle charge 0% of revenue. Their monthly price steps up as the store grows. Appstle and Seal both offer 20% off for yearly billing. Recharge, Skio, Stay AI, Loop, Appstle and Seal also sell custom plans, so a large brand may pay less than these list prices.

How much of my revenue goes to the app each year?

Take $1M a year in subscription revenue and a $40 average order. At list prices as of Nov 17, 2026, the app's share runs from 0% on Shopify Subscriptions to 2.35% on Skio. Recharge Starter takes 2.18% ($21,788 a year). Appstle takes 0.12% ($1,200). Seal and OpenSubs (free with Insider membership, $199 a month) each come to 0.24% ($2,388).

Yearly app cost as a share of subscription revenue, best-fit published plan, monthly billing except Skio (billed yearly) and Stay AI (annual contract), $40 average order, list prices as of Nov 17, 2026

Yearly subscription revenue Shopify Subscriptions Appstle Seal OpenSubs (Insider membership)¹ Loop Recharge Stay AI Skio (billed yearly)
$50k 0% ($0) 0.24% ($120) 0.24% ($119.40) 4.78% ($2,388) 3.38% ($1,688) 5.58% ($2,788) 8.65% ($4,325.50) 13.73% ($6,863)
$1M 0% ($0) 0.12% ($1,200) 0.24% ($2,388) 0.24% ($2,388) 1.12% ($11,188) 2.18% ($21,788) 1.83% ($18,338) 2.35% ($23,488)
$20M 0% ($0) custom 0.012% ($2,388) 0.012% ($2,388) 0.77% ($154,788) 1.78% ($355,988) 1.49% ($298,588) 1.78% ($355,988)

¹ OpenSubs runs on your own hosting accounts, about $45 a month ($540 a year). Hosting is not part of the membership. With hosting, the OpenSubs share is 5.86%, 0.29% and 0.015% for these rows. With hosting, Recharge Starter costs less than OpenSubs below about $57,000 a year, and Loop Starter below about $174,000.

Below about $100k a year, a flat fee is a big share of a small store's revenue. Shopify's free app costs nothing, and Seal and Appstle are the cheapest paid options. At $50k, Insider membership (4.78%) costs a larger share than Seal, Appstle, Loop or Shopify's free app. Recharge Starter costs less than OpenSubs below about $30,000 a year, and Loop Starter below about $120,000.

What do Seal's and Appstle's stepped plans cost as a share of revenue?

Seal and Appstle charge 0% of revenue. Their monthly price steps up as the store grows. As a share of revenue, Appstle's highest point is 2.0%, just after a store passes $500 a month in subscription revenue. Seal's highest point is 0.45%, at 501 subscriptions, if each subscription bills $40 a month. Past $15,000 a month, Appstle never goes above 0.67%. Past $80,000 a month, on the same $40 assumption, Seal never goes above 0.25%.

Seal's and Appstle's paid plans as a share of monthly subscription revenue, monthly billing, list prices as of Nov 17, 2026

Plan Monthly price Band (monthly subscription revenue) Share at the start of the band Share at the top of the band
Appstle Starter $10 $500 to $5,000 2.0% 0.20%
Appstle Business $30 $5,000 to $15,000 0.60% 0.20%
Appstle Business Premium $100 $15,000 to $100,000 0.67% 0.10%
Appstle Enterprise $300 $100,000 to $500,000 0.30% 0.06%
Seal Supersale $5.95 51 to 100 subscriptions ($2,040 to $4,000) 0.29% 0.15%
Seal Rising Star $9.95 101 to 250 ($4,040 to $10,000) 0.25% 0.10%
Seal Legend $24.95 251 to 500 ($10,040 to $20,000) 0.25% 0.12%
Seal Leader $89.95 501 to 2,000 ($20,040 to $80,000) 0.45% 0.11%
Seal Mega Star $199 2,001 to 50,000 ($80,040 to $2,000,000) 0.25% 0.010%
Seal Superstar $399 50,001 to 150,000 ($2,000,040 to $6,000,000) 0.020% 0.0067%

Share = monthly price ÷ monthly subscription revenue. Example: Appstle Starter at $501 a month is $10 ÷ $501 = 2.0%; at $5,000 it is $10 ÷ $5,000 = 0.20%. Both apps are free below their first band (Appstle to $500 a month, Seal to 50 subscriptions) and sell a custom plan above their last. Seal prices by number of subscriptions, not revenue; the dollar ranges assume each subscription bills $40 once a month. Billed yearly, both apps take 20% off, which lowers every share by a fifth. Sources: Appstle pricing, sealsubscriptions.com/pricing, read Nov 17, 2026.

Seal counts subscriptions, not revenue. Its FAQ says one order can be two subscriptions: subscribing to one product weekly and another monthly in the same order "will split this order in two subscriptions" (Seal FAQ, read Nov 17, 2026). If your subscriptions bill less than $40 a month, or less often than monthly, your share is higher than shown.

Appstle does not move you up a plan on its own: "we never charge our merchants without their consent." When a store reaches its plan's limit, Appstle shows the billing page to upgrade before the store can use its dashboard (Appstle help center, read Nov 17, 2026).

Read more: Seal vs Appstle vs OpenSubs: 0% apps compared, with full band tables.

Which app should I use, and which charge a flat fee?

Which charge a flat fee instead of a percentage? Seal and Appstle charge a flat monthly fee and 0% of revenue. The fee steps up as you grow: Seal costs $199 a month or less up to 50,000 subscriptions, and Appstle $100 a month or less up to $100,000 a month in subscription revenue (sealsubscriptions.com/pricing, Appstle pricing, as of Nov 17, 2026). OpenSubs is free with Insider membership, a flat $199 a month at every size. Shopify Subscriptions is free.

How to add subscriptions to your store. Install a subscription app, either Shopify's free app or one from the Shopify App Store. Add a subscription purchase option to your products, such as "Delivery every week, 15% off". To use a third-party subscription app, your store must use one of five payment gateways: Shopify Payments, PayPal Express, Authorize.net, Adyen or Stripe, and Stripe is open only to select merchants (Shopify Help Center). You then manage subscription products in your Shopify admin (Shopify Help Center).

What each app does well, in its own words (as of Nov 17, 2026):

  • Shopify Subscriptions is free and made by Shopify. Its customer portal lets customers pause, resume or cancel (Shopify Help Center).
  • Seal is free up to 50 subscriptions, charges 0% transaction fee, and offers a 30-day free trial on paid plans (sealsubscriptions.com/pricing).
  • Appstle is free up to $500 a month in subscription revenue, with "Hands-on Migration" on every plan and a 14-day free trial (App Store).
  • Loop is free up to 50 active subscriptions, bills paid plans month to month, and says "White-glove migration is included on every paid plan" (loopwork.co/pricing).
  • Recharge offers a 60-day free trial on Starter and "End-to-end migration support" on Scale (getrecharge.com/pricing).
  • Skio lists "Comprehensive Migration" ("We move 50k+ subs for breakfast") and a "Multi-Step Cancel Flow Builder" (skio.com/pricing).
  • Stay AI says "There is no implementation charge when signing up/ migrating to Stay" and lists Smart Dunning (stay.ai/pricing).

The best Shopify subscription apps shows which app fits which store size.

FAQ

Does "Shopify subscription" mean the app or my plan?

Either. Shopify's Help Center says "Shopify subscription" can mean the Shopify Subscriptions app, for selling subscription products, or Shopify's pricing plans, the levels of Shopify account you pay for (Shopify Help Center). The app is free on the Shopify App Store (App Store listing, as of Nov 17, 2026). Your Shopify plan and card processing still apply. The plans run from $39 a month (Basic) to $2,300 a month and up (Plus), as of Nov 17, 2026 (shopify.com/pricing).

Sources, method and change log

Method. Every step of the renewal comes from Shopify's developer documentation (shopify.dev) or Help Center (help.shopify.com), read Nov 17, 2026.

Fees use each app's list price on its own pricing page, read Nov 17, 2026, with this formula: yearly cost = monthly fee × 12 + revenue × percentage + (revenue ÷ $40) × per-order fee. Each app is on the cheapest published plan that fits, billed monthly, except Skio (billed yearly) and Stay AI (annual contract), as their pages lead with those prices. Seal assumes one $40 order a month per subscription. Loop uses its FAQ reading (no per-order fee), with the "loyalty order" case in a note. Card processing uses Shopify Payments' US standard online rates.

Shopify sources. About subscriptions · Purchase options · Subscription contracts · Build a subscription contract · Billing cycles · CustomerPaymentMethod · Help Center: Subscriptions, Considerations and payment gateways, Migrating saved payment methods, Third-party transaction fees, App vs pricing plan · Shopify pricing. All read Nov 17, 2026.

Other sources. Each table links the app pricing pages, read Nov 17, 2026. The text links each X post with its date and marks vendors as "vendor". Further reading: Chargeflow on recurring payments (vendor, chargeback tool).

Change log:

  • November 20, 2026: first published. Prices, ratings and Shopify pages checked Nov 17, 2026.

Compare every plan, trial and contract term in the best Shopify subscription apps.

What does the percentage cost you?

Enter last month's subscription revenue and orders to see your true rate.